20 C
Delhi
Friday, October 23, 2020

Right to protest must not hamper right to mobility of others: SC

- Advertisement -

Shaheen Bagh issue: HC asks police to look into road closure issueThe Supreme Court on Monday said Right to Protest of one section has to be in balance with others’ Right to Mobility on a public road, as everyone has the right to move from one place to another and this right cannot be prejudiced by blocking a public road to hold protests.

A bench comprising Justices Sanjay Kishan Kaul, Krishna Murari and Aniruddha Bose after nearly a gap of seven months took up the pleas against the anti-CAA protesters blocking the public road at Shaheen Bagh in Delhi.

At the beginning of the hearing the bench queried the petitioners if they were willing to withdraw the plea. One of the petitioners replied that they were not.

Advocate Amit Sahni, another petitioner in the matter, argued that these kind of incidents should not repeat in future and in the larger public interest a decision must be taken in the matter.

Advocate Mehmood Pracha, appearing for intervenors, argued before the bench that right to peacefully protest is absolute, and it is the right of the people to protest against Citizenship (Amendment) Act and National Register of Citizens as a concept.

Justice Kaul said we are not disputing your right to peacefully protest. Sahni urged the bench to keep this matter pending and an elaborate order may be passed.

Pracha submitted that “some people went to the protest place and then riots happened, and I don’t want to name them”. He added that the number of protesters cannot be shown in bad light by misusing the state machinery.

“It is not that state machinery is absolutely right. Why a person connected with a political party went their and riots happened,” argued Pracha, citing need for a universal policy on right to protest peacefully.

Justice Bose replied that the right to protest needs to be balanced out with the mobility on public road. Justice Kaul said there cannot be a universal policy as situation vary and cited process of debate in the Parliament.

“The place where it becomes problematic, we have to see where it can be balanced out,” noted the bench. Justice Kaul also appreciated the interlocutors, who helped the court in finding a solution to the matter.

The bench noted that the ongoing COVID-19 pandemic has created another dimension.

Solicitor General Tushar Mehta, representing the Centre, objected to Pracha’s argument. ‘Right to assemble is subjected to reasonable restrictions….We have places like Jantar Mantar, where protest can be held, but blocking of roads cannot be allowed,” said Mehta.

The bench agreed with Centre’s contention that people can’t claim absolute right to hold protest but said that people have right to hold peaceful protests, and this shouldn’t cause inconvenience to general public.

The bench, reserving the order in the matter in the petitions seeking removal of protestors from Shaheen Bagh, said that the matter has become infructuous due to supervening circumstance of Covid with protestors vacating the road, but added that it will pass a short order to deal with such situations.

Source: IANS

India Updates
India Updates is an independent news & Information website. Follow us for regular updates on News and Information.

Follow Us On

Related News

IFFI to take leaf from IPL playbook, focus on broadcasting event: Official

Panaji, Oct 22 (IANS): In the wake of Covid-19 pandemic-related restrictions, the Goa government is looking to take a leaf out of the Indian Premier...

India’s smartphone shipments hit record 50mn in Q3, Xiaomi leads

New Delhi, Oct 23 (IANS) Smartphone shipments in India hit an all-time high of 50 million units in the third quarter of this year,...

Next stimulus should focus on infrastructure building: Rajiv Kumar

New Delhi, Oct 23 (IANS): NITI Aayog Vice Chairman Rajiv Kumar on Thursday said that the next round of stimulus package from the government...

Covid-hit developers dole out festive offers for home buyers

New Delhi, Oct 22 (IANS) As the pandemic and the lockdowns brought housing demand to a halt, festivities seemed just apt for real estate...

IAVI, Merck, and Serum Institute of India to develop monoclonal antibodies for Covid

New Delhi, Oct 22 (IANS) IAVI, a non-profit scientific research organisation and Serum Institute of India announced an agreement with Merck to develop SARS-CoV-2...

Google brings India’s mini masterpieces to life with AI, AR

New Delhi, Oct 22 (IANS) Google Arts and Culture on Thursday announced it has partnered with the National Museum in New Delhi to showcase...

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Trending Topics In India

Covid 19 India Updates

IAVI, Merck, and Serum Institute of India to develop monoclonal antibodies for Covid

New Delhi, Oct 22 (IANS) IAVI, a non-profit scientific research organisation and Serum Institute of India announced an agreement with Merck to develop SARS-CoV-2...

IAVI, Merck, and Serum Institute of India to develop monoclonal antibodies for Covid

New Delhi, Oct 22 (IANS) IAVI, a non-profit scientific research organisation and Serum Institute of India announced an agreement with Merck to develop SARS-CoV-2...

India in ”extremely comfortable position” in terms of oxygen availability: Health Ministry

New Delhi, Oct 20 (PTI) There has been no scarcity in oxygen supply in the last 10 months with the daily production capacity enhanced...

Virus can hit recovered Covid patients once antibodies start depleting: ICMR

New Delhi, Oct 20 (IANS) Patients who have recovered from Covid-19 can again get infected by the virus once the antibodies of the viral...

Covid to reduce profits of hospitals by 35-40% this fiscal: Crisil

Mumbai, Oct 20 (IANS) Postponement of elective surgeries, revenue loss from the highly profitable medical tourism segment, and increasing safety and sanitisation costs amid...

‘India can become global PPE hub, more R&D efforts needed’

New Delhi, Oct 18 (IANS) Within six to seven months, India has become a major manufacturer of personal protective equipment (PPE) kits and even...

Trending News In India

Next stimulus should focus on infrastructure building: Rajiv Kumar

New Delhi, Oct 23 (IANS): NITI Aayog Vice Chairman Rajiv Kumar on Thursday said that the next round of stimulus package from the government...

India’s smartphone shipments hit record 50mn in Q3, Xiaomi leads

New Delhi, Oct 23 (IANS) Smartphone shipments in India hit an all-time high of 50 million units in the third quarter of this year,...

Next stimulus should focus on infrastructure building: Rajiv Kumar

New Delhi, Oct 23 (IANS): NITI Aayog Vice Chairman Rajiv Kumar on Thursday said that the next round of stimulus package from the government...

Covid-hit developers dole out festive offers for home buyers

New Delhi, Oct 22 (IANS) As the pandemic and the lockdowns brought housing demand to a halt, festivities seemed just apt for real estate...

IAVI, Merck, and Serum Institute of India to develop monoclonal antibodies for Covid

New Delhi, Oct 22 (IANS) IAVI, a non-profit scientific research organisation and Serum Institute of India announced an agreement with Merck to develop SARS-CoV-2...

Google brings India’s mini masterpieces to life with AI, AR

New Delhi, Oct 22 (IANS) Google Arts and Culture on Thursday announced it has partnered with the National Museum in New Delhi to showcase...

Trending Showbiz

IFFI to take leaf from IPL playbook, focus on broadcasting event: Official

Panaji, Oct 22 (IANS): In the wake of Covid-19 pandemic-related restrictions, the Goa government is looking to take a leaf out of the Indian Premier...

We still have much work to do in India market: Netflix

New Delhi, Oct 21 (IANS) Content streaming giant Netflix has reported slow growth in its third quarter (July-September period) despite the social distancing times,...

Vishal Bhardwaj to adapt Agatha Christie stories as film franchise

Mumbai, Oct 20 (IANS) Filmmaker Vishal Bhardwaj is developing a film franchise based on the works of famed author Agatha Christie. The series will...

‘Laxmmi Bomb’ highlights transgender community, says director Raghava Lawrence

Mumbai: The horror comedy Laxmmi Bomb, starring Akshay Kumar, is all set to release on November 9, and director Raghava Lawrence, who makes his Bollywood...

BARC India remains committed to its stakeholders

Mumbai, Oct 18 (IANS) Broadcast Audience Research Council (BARC) India on Saturday released a statement underlining the fact that the body aimed at ensuring...

Cinemas reopen: Day one sees dull start, but trade experts positive

BY NATALIA NINGTHOUJAM (IANS) Cinemas in several states including Delhi-NCR opened doors to patrons on Friday after seven months the turnout everywhere has been...

Trending Sports

Dhawan’s record ton in vain as KXIP beat DC, stay float

Dubai, Oct 20 (IANS/GloFans) A resurgent Kings XI Punjab (KXIP) on Tuesday comprehensively defeated table toppers Delhi Capitals (DC) by five wickets, despite Shikhar Dhawan's...

This IPL CSK weren’t there, says Dhoni after loss to RR

Abu Dhabi, Oct 20 (IANS) Chennai Super Kings (CSK) captain Mahendra Singh Dhoni on Monday seemed resigned to his fate after a seven-wicket defeat...

Rajasthan win comfortably, stay afloat; Chennai pushed to brink

Abu Dhabi, Oct 19 (IANS) Former champions Rajasthan Royals (RR) gave themselves a new lease of life on Monday with a convincing seven-wicket win...

KXIP crowned kings after beating MI in 2nd Super Over

Dubai, Oct 19 (IANS/GloFans) In a most dramatic contest, comprising two Super Over deciders, Kings XI Punjab (KXIP) held their nerve to eke out a...

Dhawan’s maiden ton takes DC to five-wicket win over CSK

Sharjah, Oct 17 (IANS) Shikhar Dhawan scored his maiden T20 century while Axar Patel knocked off the required 17 runs off the last over...

Latest Trending News In India

IFFI to take leaf from IPL playbook, focus on broadcasting event: Official

Panaji, Oct 22 (IANS): In the wake of Covid-19 pandemic-related restrictions, the Goa government is looking to take a leaf out of the Indian Premier...

India’s smartphone shipments hit record 50mn in Q3, Xiaomi leads

New Delhi, Oct 23 (IANS) Smartphone shipments in India hit an all-time high of 50 million units in the third quarter of this year,...

Next stimulus should focus on infrastructure building: Rajiv Kumar

New Delhi, Oct 23 (IANS): NITI Aayog Vice Chairman Rajiv Kumar on Thursday said that the next round of stimulus package from the government...

Covid-hit developers dole out festive offers for home buyers

New Delhi, Oct 22 (IANS) As the pandemic and the lockdowns brought housing demand to a halt, festivities seemed just apt for real estate...

IAVI, Merck, and Serum Institute of India to develop monoclonal antibodies for Covid

New Delhi, Oct 22 (IANS) IAVI, a non-profit scientific research organisation and Serum Institute of India announced an agreement with Merck to develop SARS-CoV-2...